Peter Cabot Gets Lost by Cat Sebastian
Day 1
Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1960
There was something deeply pathetic about lingering in town for days after graduation, but Peter Cabot had long since made his peace with being deeply pathetic.
He had packed up the trunk of his car, then unpacked it when he realized he couldn’t fit everything inside, then taken half his belongings to the Salvation Army because the idea of mailing them to the family home in Cape Cod would mean admitting he had to actually go to the family home in Cape Cod, then repacked his trunk. He helped his friends pack. He helped his favorite professor change offices. And now his lease was up and he had run out of excuses to stick around.
All that was left was to drive out to Cape Cod, resist the urge to gouge his eyes out or drive off a bridge, and then join the rest of the family on the campaign trail. It was nothing he hadn’t done before, although the last time his father had only been running for Senate. A presidential campaign meant not only five months of playacting as the world’s least convincing dutiful son, but the added horror of his awkwardness being aired on national television and appearing in the pages of Life magazine.
With a sense of acute dread, he got ready to close the trunk and slide behind the wheel.
Then, somewhere up the street, he heard the sound of a phone’s handset being slammed into the receiver and instinctively looked up. A few cars’ lengths away, beside a phone booth, stood a boy with blond hair, one hand covering his face. But Peter didn’t need to see his face to know who it was. He had spent long enough staring at Caleb Murphy, God help him, to be able to recognize him by the hair alone.
Peter considered ignoring him. Nobody wanted to be caught crying, and that was definitely what Caleb was doing behind his hand. There was just one shake of his shoulders, but it gave him away. On the other hand, Peter could hardly just drive off, leaving the kid crying on the side of the street.
He sighed and made his way down the sidewalk. However embarrassing this was, it wasn’t like they’d ever see one another again.
“Hey,” Peter said when he was about a yard away. Caleb didn’t look up. “Hey, Caleb.”
Caleb looked up, scowling despite his red eyes and tear-stained cheeks. “You,” he said, managing to imbue that syllable with a heaping dose of anger and scorn. “What do you want?”
“I, um, is something the matter?”
Caleb let out a wild laugh. “No, I just get a kick out of crying on sidewalks, don’t you? Doesn’t everyone? Go away.” He scrubbed roughly at his face with the cuff of his shirt and Peter suppressed the urge to hand him a handkerchief.
“I really can’t.”
“Oh fuck off.”
Peter was faintly surprised to hear that sort of language from Caleb. He seemed above profanity, somehow. “Look, just.” He broke off, running a hand through his hair. “I really don’t want to leave you alone like this. Is there someone you can call? Is there anything you need?”
“Ha! A bus ticket to Los Angeles. Have one handy?”
Peter took stock of the two battered suitcases by Caleb’s feet, the worn knees and frayed collar of his otherwise immaculate clothes. “No,” he said. He didn’t know if it was the old luggage or the tears or a desperate urge to do anything other than drive east that made him speak up, just that it was out of his mouth before he could second guess himself. “But I’m about to head in that direction.”
“In that direction,” Caleb scoffed. “What, westward?”
“To Los Angeles,” Peter said. “I’m visiting my aunt. Do you want a ride?”
“I don’t want your charity, Cabot.”
“It’s not—look, we can split the gas.”
Caleb regarded him with narrowed, flinty eyes, a look Peter remembered from the few classes they shared. Peter resisted the urge to squirm. “I can drive part of the way,” Caleb said finally.
Peter nearly responded that over his dead body was he letting anyone drive his car but decided they could argue about that later. He had a sense this trip would involve a fair amount of arguing. It could involve three thousand miles of uninterrupted bickering and it would still be better than his parents’ quietly simmering disappointment, though, and Peter welcomed it with the closest thing to hopeful anticipation he had experienced in months.
“Great,” Peter said. “Hop in.”
* * *Boston, Massachusetts to Albany, New York
Caleb was going to kill his sister. If she could have broken her leg next week, or—here was a thought—just not broken it at all, then his mother might have wired him the money she meant to pay him back.
“It’s fine,” Caleb had told her. “Totally fine! I have a plan B.” He did not have a plan B. He barely had a plan A. He had been living on noodles since Easter, and now Judy had to go and fall off a goddamned fence and Caleb was going to be stuck in a car with Peter fucking Cabot for days.
He knew he was being impossible; he knew this wasn’t Judy’s fault for breaking her leg, or his mother’s for never having any money, or even Peter’s for being such a fucking gentleman that he couldn’t leave Caleb crying in peace. It was his own fault for relying on anybody but himself. If he had worked a second job then he might have had more money put aside, but he was so tired, and so tired of being tired.
Now Peter was rummaging through the trunk of his car, which contained a couple of cardboard boxes in addition to a matched set of soft-looking blue leather luggage that had Caleb wanting to defect to the Soviets. As he watched, Peter took out a box labeled “records” in sloppy capitals and another box labeled “books?” and put them on the curb.
“You’re just going to leave them there?” Caleb asked, scandalized.
“This time of year, the sidewalks are filled with things students leave behind. Someone will be able to use or sell them.” Peter gestured up and down the sidewalk, which was indeed littered with boxes and odd bits of furniture. And, yes, somebody would obviously come along and take everything off to a secondhand shop, but Caleb hated the reminder that Peter could afford to just leave his belongings on the street as trash.
Also, the question mark at the end of “books?” made him feel unhinged, because how much doubt could there really be? How completely incompetent did a person have to be in order to not know what he had just put in a box?
“You wanna give me those?” Peter asked, gesturing at Caleb’s suitcases.
“No,” Caleb snapped, and shoved his luggage into the trunk. Then he went to the passenger side and slid in, conscious that he was acting like a brat but not really having the energy to act any other way. It was stupidly satisfying to lash out at somebody, especially somebody like Peter Cabot who couldn’t be hurt one way or the other.
He sat silently—sulking, he supposed, was technically what he was doing—while Peter made his way out of Cambridge and into the Boston traffic toward, Caleb presumed, the turnpike. Despite having lived here for four years, Caleb only had the vaguest notion of Massachusetts geography. He only had the vaguest knowledge of geography, period, but that was only because maps were the devil’s work. But that meant he’d have to trust that Cabot knew what he was doing, and Caleb hated trusting people, especially people like Peter Cabot.
Still, Cabot seemed to be a competent driver, and when he followed a sign reading “Massachusetts Turnpike, West,” Caleb figured he could at least be trusted to point the vehicle in the general direction of California.
Caleb shifted in his seat and cursed himself for leaving his books in his suitcase because now he had nothing to do but stare out the window and seethe. Cabot tuned the radio to the broadcast of a baseball game in which Caleb had no interest whatsoever, and regardless of how rude Caleb was being, he wasn’t rude enough to ask a man to change the station in his own car.
It was two in the afternoon by the time they left Boston behind them, and Caleb hadn’t eaten breakfast, let alone lunch. Only the rumble of the car’s engine covered up the embarrassing noises his stomach was making, so he was relieved when Cabot casually asked if Caleb minded stopping for an early dinner. “I thought I could wait for dinner, but I’m starved,” Cabot said, with a nervous laugh as if he shouldn’t admit to such a plebeian requirement as food.
“Fine,” Caleb said.
“There’s a Howard Johnson’s in a couple of miles,” Cabot said. “Is that okay?”
“It’s fine,” Caleb said.
When they got out of the car, Cabot rolled his neck and stretched his shoulders as if he had spent the past few hours at crew practice—Caleb hated himself for knowing that Peter Cabot did things like crew, but there was no avoiding that kind of knowledge about someone like Cabot, one acquired it through some complicated process of social osmosis—rather than sitting in a car. Caleb, by contrast, primly dusted off his slacks and opened the door to the diner, pointedly waiting for Cabot to join him.
A waitress in a blue uniform led them to a table where Cabot ordered two hamburgers with extra fries and a milkshake and Caleb ordered a frankfurter that cost 35 cents and a glass of water. Cabot had better not plan on splitting the check down the middle, that much was for sure. When the food came, Caleb greedily ate his hot dog and the french fries that came with it, and by the time his plate was empty, he felt better. It was always annoyingly predictable that he felt less ornery after a decent meal. He might have thought that by now he’d have made the connection between an empty stomach and a bad temper. Maybe one day he’d be able to eat before he was half starved, and without weighing pennies and nickels against the gnawing in his gut.
“My God, I was hungry,” Cabot said, shoving his plate away from him.
Caleb said nothing, because Cabot didn’t look like he knew the meaning of the word. There was no way he had missed a meal in his life. He sure didn’t look it. Despite himself, Caleb let his gaze drift to the breadth of Cabot’s shoulders and the suggestion of muscled biceps beneath the rumpled cotton of his oxford shirt. Then he noticed that Cabot had only eaten half his fries.
“You still have food left,” Caleb said, and then immediately wanted to bite his tongue. It was no business of his if Cabot left food on his plate, and he didn’t like having hinted that it mattered to him. Caleb knew how to behave among rich people, for heaven’s sake; he hadn’t spent the past four years at Harvard for nothing. It was just that being on the phone with his mother made all that stuff float to the surface, just like it made his accent come out. He hated that he had let Cabot get to him. But if Cabot thought that Caleb was acting strange, he didn’t betray it.
Cabot shrugged. “You can have them if you want. The second hamburger and the milkshake were kind of overkill. My eyes were bigger than my stomach,” he said sheepishly.
That startled a laugh out of Caleb. “My mother says that.”
“All mothers say that.”
Caleb had thought that the Cabots wouldn’t refer to anything so vulgar as a stomach. They probably dined in a vast marble hall, eating caviar off of plates that were trimmed in gold. Caleb’s notions of how the very rich lived in their native habitats were entirely based on what he had seen in the movies. His friends were mainly the kids of doctors and lawyers, which was plenty rich as far as Caleb was concerned, an entire world away from how he had grown up, but also a world away from people like the Cabots.
Somehow, the plate of fries was now in front of him, and he couldn’t have said whether he had pulled it across the table or whether Cabot had pushed it. Either way, Caleb was eating them, dipping fries into the puddle of ketchup on the side of the plate.
When the check came, Cabot put three dollars on the table, which more than covered both their meals. Caleb bristled. He had had enough of being a charity case and wasn’t going to tolerate it from Peter Cabot. Eating french fries so they didn’t go to waste was one thing; letting someone pay for your dinner was something else altogether.
“That’s too much,” Caleb snapped.
“Oh,” Cabot said. He wasn’t exactly blushing, but he looked caught out. “I—how much should it be?”
Caleb sighed. He handed one of the dollar bills back to Cabot and put down forty-one cents for his own share—thirty-five for the food, and a fifteen percent tip that he rounded up to six cents. “Your meal was $1.70. Your tip is a quarter, bringing your total to $1.95. You put down two dollars, so I owe you five cents.” He picked up one of the nickels that he had placed on the bill and held it out to Cabot.
“Uh,” said Cabot. “Leave it for the waitress.”
“That would be an eighteen percent tip,” Caleb pointed out.
“I don’t usually count it out like that. I just make sure I’m leaving at least fifteen percent.”
Caleb realized that the three dollars hadn’t been meant to cover his own meal, but to provide the waitress with a substantial tip. “Three dollars would have been almost a seventy-five percent tip.”
“It’s only an extra dollar.”
Caleb felt his face turning red and hated Cabot for it. “Only a dollar,” he repeated.
“I mean, I know it’s a lot for some people. It’s probably a lot for the waitress. But it isn’t for me.”
“You can’t throw your money around like that.”
That, somehow, was the wrong thing to say, because Cabot, for the first time that day, the first time in the four years Caleb had been acquainted with him, lost his facade of good humor. “I’m not throwing it around. I’m using it. It’s mine to use, and if I want to give it all to diner waitresses, then that’s what I’ll do, and it isn’t your job to tell me otherwise.”
“But why—”
“I’m trying not to be an asshole!” The words came out far louder than Cabot could possibly have intended, and Caleb felt judgmental gazes from several tables around them.
“Fine,” Caleb snapped, and got to his feet, figuring he could wait at the car while Cabot did whatever the hell he fucking pleased with all his money.
* * *Upstate New York
Peter clearly hadn’t thought this through. He seldom did, according to his father, most of his coaches, and those of his professors who paid him any attention beyond his last name. If he had thought ahead even slightly, he would have realized that traveling across the continent would involve overnight stays, and that someone who very obviously had no money would want to cut down on costs by sharing a room. He had been all set to ask the motel clerk for two rooms when instead Caleb spoke up and asked for a double.
Sharing the car with someone who obviously hated him had been bad enough, and Peter had been looking forward to having some space to himself for the night. Also, he hadn’t shared a room since his freshman year of college and wasn’t looking forward to doing it again.
Besides, there was the other matter.
The awkwardness gathered around them while, on separate sides of the room, they opened their suitcases and took out the items they’d need that night.
“Look,” Peter said when he couldn’t take it anymore. Caleb looked up, a comb in one hand. This would all be easier if he weren’t so—handsome wasn’t quite the word. He was interesting to look at, in a way that made Peter never want to look away. He was about Peter’s height, so maybe five foot ten, but thinner. Rangy, even. He had a pointy chin and a pointy nose and a fall of sandy hair that kept wanting to land in his eyes. His lips were, at this moment, pressed together in an impatient line, but Peter knew that when he was interested in something, like a history lecture, he parted them slightly, and sometimes his tongue would dart out to wet his lower lip.
This would all be so much easier if Peter hadn’t spent quite so much time watching this man.
“I have to,” Peter stammered. Because of course he stammered. His brain and his body had an unerring ability to work in perfect synergy to fuck things up. “I should have told you before you even got in the car. It was really unfair for me to have done this, I just didn’t realize, and you have to believe me when I say that I’m sorry.”
“What is it?” Caleb asked, his face even paler than usual, barely illuminated by the weak light cast by the motel’s table lamp. His fingers tightened around his comb until Peter thought he could see it bend under the strain.
“I just…” Peter sucked in a breath and let it out. He had only said this twice, and both of those times it had been to what you might call a sympathetic audience. “I’m gay.”
“You’re gay,” Caleb repeated.
“Yeah, I’m, er, I like men.”
“I know what gay means,” Caleb snapped. “Why are you telling me this?”
“Because we’re spending the night in the same room and I know that not everybody would be comfortable.”
“You were giving me a chance to—what? To tell you that I revile homosexuals?” There was something about the way Caleb spoke those last two words that made Peter think he was quoting someone, but this clearly wasn’t the time to ask. “That I rebuke you and your perversions?”
Peter felt his cheeks heat. “No, I should have told you before we got in the car.”
“Oh, Caleb,” Caleb said in what Peter gathered was meant to be an imitation of his own accent, “do you want a free ride to Los Angeles with me, a queer?”
“You make it sound ridiculous.” Mary and all the saints, this man could not make anything easy, could he?
“Because it is ridiculous.”
“I’m trying to make you comfortable!”
Caleb regarded him appraisingly, then looked at the comb he held, as if surprised to find it still in his hand. He placed it carefully onto his nightstand. “I have it on good authority that you can tell at fifty paces that I’m bent. Are you telling me you didn’t know?”
“I, um.” Peter blushed. “I thought—I mean, I thought you might be, but I haven’t figured out how to really tell, and I didn’t want to presume.”
“You didn’t want to presume.” He shut his eyes, as if praying for deliverance. “Did you tell me because you want to get into my pants? Because if you think I’m paying for the car ride with blow jobs, let me tell you I’m worth far more than the price of a Greyhound ticket.”
“No!” Peter protested. His cheeks were burning, and he fought the urge to bury his face in his hands.
Caleb, however, did exactly that. When he looked up, he seemed to have come to a decision, and he spoke in a carefully patient tone. “God help me. Listen, Cabot—”
“Please call me Peter.”
Caleb waved dismissively. “You can’t just go around telling people you’re gay. You’ll get hurt.”
“I’m not worried—”
“You should be. There are plenty of people who don’t care that you’re a Cabot, but they sure as shit will care that you’re a—”
“I know that,” Peter said. “I don’t go around telling just anybody. I’ve hardly told anyone. Ever. I just thought you were a safe person. After everything you said in class, I thought you’d be safe.” There was more to it than that and Peter knew there was. He didn’t want to let anyone else into his life who didn’t know him for who he was. If he had wanted to hide all the important parts of himself and still be found wanting, he could have driven east instead of west.
“You thought I’d be safe enough not to murder you, but not so safe that I’d be comfortable sharing a room with a gay man.”
“Yes,” Peter said, feeling as stupid as he ever had. This was what his father did, twist his words around until Peter was left defending some scrap of truth that ceased to hold any meaning. “Look, I was just trying to not be an asshole.”
“I take it this is a new endeavor?”
He said it so cattily and so immediately that Peter wanted to laugh. “You know what? Don’t worry about it. You’re right that it’s new.” Peter gathered up his toothbrush and some clean clothes. “I’m going to take a shower and go to sleep. You can turn the light off whenever you like.”
He stood under the spray of hot water for a long time, wondering what in hell he had gotten himself into.
* * *Caleb knew he was being awful. If his mother knew how rude her son was being to a man he ought to be grateful to, she’d walk all the way from Tennessee just to strangle him in his sleep.
The trouble was that Caleb didn’t handle gratitude terribly well. At 21, he had had his fill. First, there had been the secondhand clothes left on the porch by people from church. Then came the cans of food left after a bad winter, casseroles brought over on the flimsiest of pretexts. Later there were dollar bills slipped into his mother’s palm when his stepfather wasn’t looking. All Caleb had wanted was to get out, to get as far away from Hickory Creek as he could, far from broken tractors and empty bellies and his too-thin mother. He wanted to fend for himself, to stand on his own feet. But even with his scholarships, he wouldn’t have been able to go to Harvard without the church raising money to pay for his bus ticket to Boston.
And it rankled that not even a week after graduating, he was already dependent on somebody. And it couldn’t even be some normal person. No, it had to be Peter Cabot.
They had only taken a handful of classes together. Under ordinary circumstances, Caleb might not have remembered the name or face of one classmate in a lecture hall, especially one who spoke as seldom as Cabot did.
But Peter Cabot was the sort of person you were always passively aware of, like it or not. It wasn’t that he was good-looking, although Caleb grudgingly conceded that he was. Most of the Cabots were, with wavy dark hair, bright blue eyes, sharp cheekbones, and a jawline you could cut things on—sort of like fancy department store models of Gregory Peck. But Peter’s version of the typical family features was like the last page of a carbon copy—blurred and vaguely disappointing. He was handsome, but in a way that made you think about how much better looking the rest of his family was.
There was more to it than that, though. Peter had an air of taking up more space than he actually did. It was probably just the money and entitlement, but there was some deeply unfair genetic magic at work too. In the other Cabots, this quality showed itself in charisma, or the sort of magnetism that was going to make Senator Cabot his party’s next nominee for president.
You couldn’t open a newspaper without reading about some Cabot or another. One of Peter’s uncles was a judge and the others were Washington bigwigs of some sort. Before that, there had been an ambassador and an assortment of mustache-twirling robber barons. The Cabot name was plastered all over buildings in Massachusetts and all over history books. All Peter had to do was show up, and he’d go on to things that were as impressive as the accomplishments of the rest his family. As far as Caleb could tell, Peter Cabot was a mediocre student and hardly a genius. But his family name and connections would let him drift into success.
Caleb, meanwhile, was exhausted by having fought so hard just to get where Peter had gotten effortlessly. He knew jealousy was pointless and resentment was a waste of his already pitiful supply of energy, but he couldn’t help it. When Peter unpacked his suitcase, Caleb found himself bitterly wondering how much his pajamas cost (surely more than Caleb’s own pair, which he had bought at the Cambridge Woolworth after realizing that none of the other boys in his dormitory slept in their shorts and undershirts) and whether he used ordinary toothpaste or some secret rich people brand that Caleb had never heard of. Maybe rich people had ways of looking like that, with their hair just right and their teeth super shiny. Caleb knew he looked fine, better than fine if your tastes ran to pale, lanky men. But Peter Cabot was something else entirely.
And he was queer. Caleb hadn’t seen that coming at all. He was by no means an expert at identifying fellow travelers, but Cabot seemed, well, too boring to be queer. Did his perfect family know? Caleb doubted it. Cabot had said himself that he hadn’t told many people. But he had told Caleb. He had given Caleb enough information to make life very difficult for him. Caleb still couldn’t figure out why in hell Cabot would tell a near stranger that kind of thing.
Because Cabot was an idiot, probably. He was an idiot, and he didn’t believe in a world in which things didn’t go just swimmingly for him. He thought he could reveal all his secrets and nobody would shun him or beat him up or pray for his soul.
He had said he told Caleb because he thought a man would want to know he was sharing a motel room with a queer. It had never occurred to Caleb that he ought to disclose his proclivities to his roommates, because it was none of their fucking business. The fact that Cabot thought otherwise made Caleb wonder exactly how ashamed Cabot was of who he was and who he wanted. That made Caleb feel equal parts sympathetic and fed up. It had been a long time since Caleb was ashamed of himself and he didn’t want any part of it.
Above all he didn’t want any part of feeling bad for Peter Cabot. He wanted to resent the man for who he was and what he stood for. That was comfortable and familiar, a cozy blanket in the middle of a shit show of a week.
When he heard the bathroom door open, Caleb pretended to already be asleep.