Earl Lessons by Valerie Bowman

Chapter Thirty-Four

“Iwouldn’t blame you if you call me out, Bell,” David said later that afternoon as he sat in a large leather chair in the study. David was nursing a brandy and spinning the glass around on the desktop in front of him. He’d asked the other men to give them their privacy. This conversation between himself and Bell was overdue. “Though I must say in Brighton, a solid beating is much more expedient,” David continued. “We don’t do this ‘calling out’ nonsense. Far too formal. If you want to meet me out on the lawn for fisticuffs, however, I’ll gladly—”

“Call you out? For what?” Bell was drinking a cup of tea as if they were at afternoon garden party, for Christ’s sake, instead of in the middle of a bloody catastrophe.

David widened his eyes and stared at the marquess as if he’d lost his mind. “Ruining your sister? Remember?”

Bell threw back his head and laughed. “You didn’t ruin her. You’re marrying her. Mother is thrilled, by the by.”

David tossed back the remainder of the contents in his glass and stood to walk over to the sideboard and pour himself another. “Well, that makes one person in your family who’s thrilled. Annabelle certainly isn’t.”

Bell frowned. “What gives you that idea? I assumed she was partial to you, or she wouldn’t have been, ahem, doing whatever you two were doing that necessitates the wedding.”

David shook his head. “Partial, perhaps. But wanting to marry, never.”

Bell shook his head. “I don’t understand.”

“Frankly, neither do I. Have you ever wondered why your sister has refused all offers of marriage?” David replied.

“I’ve wondered, but according to Annabelle, she simply hadn’t met the chap she wanted to spend the rest of her life with.”

“I’m not certain that chap exists,” David replied.

Bell frowned again. “What do you mean?”

“Your sister has told me time and again that she’s singularly uninterested in marriage. She wasn’t planning to marry Murdock, and she isn’t at all happy about having to marry me. She’s opposed to the institution itself.”

Bell plucked at his lower lip. “Did she tell you that?”

“In nearly as many words.” David left his glass on the desktop and turned to face his friend. It hadn’t occurred to him until this moment, but Bell might be able to answer the question Annabelle wouldn’t. “The other night, when I was alone with Annabelle, I raised my hand sharply while standing next to her. I meant her no harm, of course, but she fell to the floor and curled into a ball.” David took a deep breath and met his friend’s eyes. “Why would she do that, Bell? Has a man ever struck her?”

David had never seen the Marquess of Bellingham at a loss for words. Nor had he ever seen the confident spy turn pale, and he’d certainly never heard all the breath rush from his lungs. But when all three things happened simultaneously, it caused the hair on the back of David’s neck to prickle.

Panic clutched at David’s middle. “Please tell me ‘no,’” he breathed, still carefully watching Bell’s face.

“No,” Bell finally uttered, but his face remained colorless, and he turned his head to stare straight ahead at the wall, shaken, as if he’d seen a ghost. “At least, not that I ever witnessed, but…”

David sat up straighter in his chair. He leaned toward Bell. “But what? What is it? Why is she so afraid of men?”

Bell braced an elbow atop the desk and let his head drop into his palm. He took a long, deep breath. “God, Elmwood. How could I have been so bloody stupid all these years?”

“What? Tell me.” David’s voice was rough, demanding.

“Our father,” Bell continued. He lifted his head to stare at the wall again. His jaw was tight. “The blackguard drank to excess and became abusive when he did so. He beat Mother, and…at times…he beat me.”

David swallowed the lump in his throat that had been forming ever since he’d seen the look of pure anguish on Bell’s face. “And Annabelle witnessed it?”

Bell nodded slowly. A pulse ticked in his jaw. “I’m ashamed to say she did. The bastard never struck her that I’m aware of. But she saw things. On more occasions than I care to recall.”

David pressed his lips together and briefly closed his eyes. What did he say to his strong, proud friend, who was admitting something that had to be beyond difficult? David didn’t trust himself not to speak in anger.

The pulse continued to throb in Bell’s jaw and a look of pure hatred shone in his ice-blue eyes. “Of course, that was when I was a child. When it wasn’t a fair fight. The moment I became old enough, big enough to hit back and do damage, the bastard stopped. Annabelle was still quite young then. I…I mistakenly believed she hadn’t been affected, perhaps didn’t even remember it.” Bell shook his head. “I’ve been a fool.”

Another lump formed in David’s throat. He could only imagine what it had cost his friend to stand up to his own father that way. No wonder Bell was so strong.

“Annabelle thinks a man striking his wife is normal behavior,” David finally breathed, his mind racing. “Which would explain her fear. She also told me she didn’t want any children.” David’s chest was tight. It all made sense now. So much sense. Awful sense, but it explained all of Annabelle’s reticence.

Bell nodded gravely. “It makes me ill to think that, but it stands to reason. I’ve heard her mention things through the years about not wanting to ‘belong’ to a man.”

So many things made sense now. David nodded toward Bell’s teacup. “It’s why you don’t drink, isn’t it?”

“Yes,” Bell said, lifting his cup in the semblance of a salute. “Though for years, I’ve lived with the regret of not coming to my father’s bedside when he was dying. The man was a bastard most of his life, and I never could forgive him. But apparently he was regretful in the end.”

David reached out and clapped a hand on his friend’s shoulder. “I don’t blame you. And if you ask me, you should have no regrets. Any man who beats a woman or child isn’t worthy of any title, especially that of ‘father’.”

Bell nodded, once.

“As for drinking, you must know you’re nothing like him,” David continued.

The marquess stared unseeing at the wall again. “Perhaps, but I never trusted that I wouldn’t turn into him if I drank. That is a fear I’ve never been able to conquer.”

“That sort of violence isn’t in you, Bell,” David assured him, pulling his hand away.

“I hope not, Elmwood. But I don’t intend to ever find out.” Bell stood and walked toward the door.

“Where are you going?” David asked, turning in his seat to face him.

“To have a long overdue talk with my sister.”