Discreet by Nicole French

15

We drove back to the lake in silence, Will keeping my hand clasped firmly in his lap, but it wasn’t until he pulled up in front of my stairs that I fully realized the night wasn’t over. Sure, I’d asked him to take me home. And yeah, I’d meant beyond just a drop-off. But he hadn’t said anything else, hadn’t made a move. I had assumed that in the twenty-minute drive from Curly’s, he’d changed his mind, like he always did.

But then he turned off the engine and pulled the keys out of the ignition.

“I—you—what are you doing now?” I asked.

Will’s fingers brushed over my knuckles, and we both watched the movement for a moment. I was the first to look up.

“Do you want to come down?” My voice was small, unsure. Hell, I was unsure. Was I ready for this? For what I was asking for? I didn’t know. But I knew I wanted it. Will made me feel like a whole person, in a way I wasn’t ever sure I would again. He kissed me like I was the key to his survival. Or maybe like he was the key to mine.

Will paused. I could understand it, sort of. He’d been through enough tonight. If the guy had a severe phobia of people and had forced himself into a crowded bar for my sake, I could understand if he was averse to sex too. He wanted it—clearly—but some things superseded desire. Sex made a person vulnerable, and I had a feeling that I’d never feel so vulnerable, so naked, than when I was alone with Will.

“The only person there will be my mom,” I said. “And you already know her. And there’s a good chance she’s already out for the night, if she’s had enough gin and tonics.”

Will looked up. “Is it really that bad with her? You—and others—seem to bring it up a lot. But she doesn’t seem like that during the day.”

I shrugged. “She’s very functional. Until she’s not. The nights are the worst. She doesn’t do well with being alone.”

Will nodded, suddenly looking past me, like he was almost somewhere else. “Yeah,” he replied. “I get that.”

Before I could ask what he meant, he grabbed a fleece jacket off his seat and got out of the truck. I followed suit, and he met me around the other side, taking my hand again naturally after he finished zipping up his jacket.

“Do you think we could slow down?” he asked. “Maybe just go sit somewhere and…and talk?”

I nodded, slightly relieved. As much as I wanted to, I probably wasn’t ready to dive into anything just yet. I wanted him so badly, but something inside me said it was better to wait. Being with Will made me feel like I was racing to jump off a cliff without knowing how far down I was going to fall.

“Sure,” I said. “Why don’t we go down and light a fire by the dock?”

Unfortunately, a fire was already lit. When we rounded the far corner of the property around the shack, we found Mama sitting there, semi-awake while she stared into the flames. She started as we arrived, then relaxed and smiled when she saw who was with me.

“Well, if it isn’t William,” she said, standing up with a wobble. A glass in her hand clinked—yes, the gin and tonics were definitely still going.

Will awkwardly accepted a hug, and I resisted the urge to hide my face in my hands. If Mama was past the point where she could read any kind of social cues, then she was at least three or four drinks in.

“Come, come,” Mama urged us. “Sit down. Take a seat. I didn’t expect you kids back for a long time yet, if ever.” She winked. “I guess you’re a gentleman, William. Can I get you anything?”

Will shook his head as he sank into one of the Adirondack chairs. “No, Ms. Sharp, I’m good, thanks.”

“And how was the date?”

“Mama!” I chided her, suddenly even more embarrassed. Was that what this was? A date?

Will rubbed his lips together—lips that had been all over my collarbone, neck, the tops of my breasts, maybe fifteen minutes ago. Okay, maybe date qualified now. I flushed, and he quirked an eyebrow at me.

“It was good,” he said to Mama. “Although the music wasn’t really my style.”

I blanched. “It was Mike Grady’s band, Mama. You remember them.”

“Ohhhh, yes!” Mama crowed. “My, my. No wonder you didn’t care for it. Michael sounds like a vacuum cleaner when he sings. William, have you heard Maggie play yet? I swear, she really does sound like an angel.”

“Mama.”

“Margaret, hush.” Mama stood back up. “I’ll be right back. She hasn’t played since she’s been here. Let’s see if we can get her to come out of her sad sack, shall we?”

“Mama,” I protested again, but she waved her hand in the air as she tottered back to the house. I turned to Will. “Sorry,” I said bashfully. “She, um, gets like this when she’s had a few…”

“Lil.” Will’s voice called my attention. “Stop. I get it. And it’s fine.”

I shrugged. “It’s not. But right now, all I can do is be here.”

“That’s all anyone could ask for.”

We lapsed into silence, listening to the sound of the lake water lapping at the dock until Mama’s footsteps crunched across pine needles. She rounded the shack carrying my nicest and most prized guitar like it was nothing more than a broom handle.

“Mama, be careful!” I cried when she stumbled over a rock and almost fell down. I jumped up and ran over to take the guitar from her hands, but she twisted away from me, then fell into her chair with a thump. I winced as the edge of my guitar bumped her knee. Better that than the chair arm, I guessed.

“Oh relax,” she told me. “Here, play us something pretty.”

I eyed the shiny black wood. “Mama, I really don’t think—”

“Come on now, Maggie Mae. I didn’t scrimp and save for all those years of lessons just so you could ignore your mama. You need to play. How long has it been?”

She thrust the guitar at me, until finally I had to take it, lest it fall to the ground.

“Christ, Mama,” I muttered as I rescued it. “This is a Martin D-35, the same guitar Johnny Cash played on. You don’t just toss that around.”

“Well, let’s hear you play it, then,” Mama replied. She glanced at Will with a sly smile. “William, I bet you’re the kind of man who likes a nice cold beer when he sits around a fire, aren’t you? I’m gonna get one for myself. Would you like one?”

Will glanced at me, but I shrugged. I had meant what I said at the bar.

“That sounds great, Ms. Sharp.” Will gave a friendly nod, and the uncharacteristic gesture practically lit up his face.

Mama practically melted right there, batting her eyes at him. I just rolled mine.

We sat there for a second while Mama went back to the house, letting the sounds of the night fall around us like a cloak.

“Why haven’t you played in a while?” Will asked quietly.

I tried to ignore the natural way the wood felt, curved over my knee. I tried to ignore the easy feel of the neck resting in my palm. The way the strings seemed to call to my fingertips. I closed my eyes, wishing the feeling away. But it wouldn’t go.

For a second I was back on that stage. I could see the reps my manager had brought for the night, mostly just shadows in the back of the room. I could feel the heat of the stage lights shining down on me, demanding that I be someone else again. That I ignore everything that had happened to me, put on a smiling face, pretend that I was okay when in reality, my insides were still thoroughly shattered.

I could feel, again, my fingers slipping on the strings. The squeal of the wrong chord. The hot rush of tears burning down my face as I ran off the stage. I blinked and shook my head, focusing again on the sound of the water tickling the banks, the light breeze through the pine trees, the crackle of the fire.

New York was a long way away.

“I just don’t love it anymore,” I said. “Not like I used to.”

“I don’t believe that.”

I looked up. “Why would you say that?”

The firelight shone off Will’s hair, turning the blond highlights on top a burnished bronze. His eyes, almost black in the night, were as deep, almost mournful, as ever. But the firelight danced in their depths.

“Because the second you took that guitar, your whole body lit up,” he replied. He picked up a stick and started poking at the logs. “It was like that,” he said as a thrill of embers flew up into the night air. “Sparks.”

Our eyes met across the fire as the sparks disappeared into the black, and for a moment, I couldn’t move. Will swallowed visibly, the movement causing the muscles in his neck to flex. It was easy sometimes to forget how handsome he really was. His beard covered most of his face, but the shadows cast from the fire still played up cheekbones and hinted at a jawline that looked like it belonged in a museum, not around a campfire. His eyes, I knew, were as green as the lake at twilight, but with gold flecks that looked exactly like the sparks he had just teased from the logs. I knew what his chest looked like without that fleece on—knew exactly how his sun-kissed skin pulled taut over the sleek, elegant lines of his torso, which looked particularly good when he had water dripping all over it.

But now I couldn’t help wondering what the rest of him looked like. If his lower half was as well built as the top.

Then our eyes met again. As if he could see my illicit thoughts reflected on my face, Will’s gaze reflected a different kind of fire—one I suddenly felt burning deeply within me as well. Slowly, his gaze dropped, pouring over my body with such intensity it was like he was actually touching me.

Sparks. Yeah.

He exhaled, and swallowed again.

“Play something,” he said, his voice slightly hoarse.

I cleared my throat, suddenly aware again that I was still holding my guitar. I looked down at it. Once I knew this shape like I knew my own body. Now it was like holding a stranger. And somehow, I didn’t think that was just because of how long it had been since I had played.

“What—what do you want to hear?”

“Um…” Will’s voice sounded strained. “Just—just play something. Now. Please.”

I opened my mouth to remark just how odd it was that he was saying please—I honestly wasn’t sure I had heard Will say anything nice to anyone since I had met him. But before I could reply, we were interrupted.

“Margaret can play just about anything,” Mama said as she stepped back into the clearing. She handed Will a beer and kept the other for herself.

Will accepted the mug with a brief nod, although something told me that the cheap beer Mama had poured into the frigid glass wasn’t quite up to Will’s standards. Based on his home, the tea he had served me, I already knew that he had a quiet preference for the finer things in life.

“Do you ever…?” he asked me.

I shook my head.

“Maggie doesn’t drink,” Mama confirmed. “Not like I haven’t tried to get her to lighten up for years. But you can’t move a mountain, I should say.”

I looked down at the strings, strummed them lightly, and cringed. Well, I wasn’t going to be playing a damn thing with that tuning.

“What’s your favorite music, William?” Mama asked as she retook her seat, and I proceeded to tune the guitar.

Will shrugged.

“When Margaret was little, I didn’t need a record player or a stereo. I’d put on the radio, and she would listen. Ten minutes later, she could play the song.” She looked at me. “What’d they call it, honey? You have perfect pinch?”

Will chuckled into his glass, and I rolled my eyes. “Pitch, Mama. Perfect pitch.”

“Pitch,” Mama told Will. “Name any song. My baby can play it for you.” She took another long sip of her beer, as if that covered everything.

Will looked at me curiously. “Really?”

I shrugged and focused on tuning the last string. “Yeah. Pretty much.”

I didn’t say that having perfect pitch had been as much of a hindrance as it had been a blessing. My dependence on my ear was the reason I didn’t know how to read music, and so had failed just about every music class I’d taken at NYU. I had dreams of coming out of college a classically trained guitarist. So much for dreams.

“‘Gimme Shelter,’” Will said. “Try that one.”

Immediately I strummed the opening chords to the Rolling Stones’ famous tune.

Will’s eyes brightened considerably. “Wow. Okay, then. How about ‘The Boxer’?”

I rolled my eyes. “Seriously.” My fingers tickled the strings faster than I could think out the complicated opening pattern to Simon and Garfunkel’s hit. “Come on, now. Challenge me.”

Will smirked. “How about ‘Stairway to Heaven’?”

“Sure, I know that. Me and every other eighth grade boy on the planet.” I laughed while I teased out the famous opening pattern to the Led Zeppelin classic, but stopped a few bars in. “Satisfied? Someone’s a classic rock junkie, I see.”

“Just means he has good taste,” Mama cut in with a nod to Will.

Will just nodded in agreement. “The classics never go out of style.”

“Play one of yours, Margaret,” Mama urged with her glass. “For me.”

I froze. “I don’t know, Mama. I haven’t practiced in so long…”

“I’d like to hear one,” Will said.

The open curiosity in his face was something I hadn’t seen before. His voice was barely audible over the crackle of the fire, but his eyes were what really stilled me. Gone was the cold, harsh man who kept showing up on our dock like a wet stray dog. Gone were the guarded looks. The suspicion. The not-so-hidden anger. The hurt.

Now I only saw a face that was warm. Open. Hopeful.

And as much as it scared me, in that second, I knew. I knew I’d play anything he wanted, in front of anyone, if he would look at me like that again.

I gulped. “Um, okay. I guess…sure.”

And so, for the first time since I had run off that stage and fled New York in both terror and shame, I picked out the melody of the song I had written once, long ago, as a way to voice those emotions that couldn’t speak aloud by themselves.

It was a song about loneliness. A song about being saved. A song about staying with someone long after you should, and how it broke you to do it.

The last note hung in the air for what seemed like eons, and when I finished, even the fire seemed silent. I exhaled, enjoying for a moment the elation that always came when I played my own music, my own heart. There was a space that opened up where nothing else existed but those notes, those resonances. The sound of my voice, the unity of my fingers on the strings or the keys. Just me. Just music. Nothing else mattered.

I opened my eyes and looked to Mama and Will, hoping to see at least a bit of that same contentment on their faces, the same that I felt at the end.

“Oh, honey,” Mama said as she wiped a tear from her eye. “You always do this to me when you play, sweetheart. Beautiful, just beautiful. Wasn’t it beautiful, William?”

I looked to Will, ready for his more taciturn answer, but hoping for maybe a little more than usual. Music always made me open up more too. Maybe it would do the same for him.

But he said nothing. His face had shuttered, and the frown line over his brow had reappeared. His mouth was slightly open while he looked at me, an expression that quickly morphed into a glare.

“Will?” I ventured, my voice small. I tried to be light, to mask the way his reaction hurt. Why it should hurt so much, I didn’t care to explore. “Will, what’s wrong?”

He stood up in a sudden hurry.

“Thank you for the beer, Ms. Sharp,” he said stiffly to my mother. “I should be going.”

“William,” she protested. “Sit back down and finish your drink. Don’t be a rude guest to Maggie.”

But the look on his face said he would rather do anything but that. He glanced between us, his eyes wide. Panicked.

“Will,” I protested. “What’s—”

“I have to go,” he said, and before either of us could respond, practically ran out of the clearing. Mama and I listened to the sound of his steps tromping up the deck, and watched him a few moments later as he made his way up the rest of the stairs.

“Well,” Mama said as she sat back into her chair. She shook her head and took another long drink of beer. “I don’t know what crawled up his bum, but I think tomorrow you’d best find out.”

I frowned. “What? Why?”

“Because,” she said as she set her beer on the ground. Her speech was slowing, a sure sign that soon, she’d be asleep. “That’s what friends do, Maggie.”

“Mama, I really don’t think he wants that.”

“That’s what friends do,” she repeated as her head lolled to the side.

“Mama, come on,” I said, rising from the chair and pulling her up. If she passed out here, she’d be impossible to move until morning, and I’d end up sleeping on the grass to make sure she didn’t accidentally stumble into the lake.

After I helped her to bed and put away my guitar, I stood for a moment on the top deck, looking out at the lake. Across the calm waters, a light flashed through the trees—a car arriving, maybe, or a porch light turning on and off. And I knew my mother was right. I needed to be there. Now.